Choosing Between Daycare and a Nanny

Is there anything more important to parents than choosing the best care for their children? We know the stakes are high, and we want to outline the key differences as you evaluate your options. Simply comparing costs doesn’t give the full picture. Below are some pros and cons for each choice.

Why Many Families Prefer Hiring a Nanny

A nanny is the most premium option because it provides the highest level of care and the most benefits to your family. This includes:

  • Consistency and Connection: A nanny becomes a stable, trusted presence in your child’s life, supporting emotional development and reducing separation anxiety.
  • Customization: From nap schedules, to food preferences, to learning and parenting styles, a nanny adapts to your family’s needs. Additionally, most nannies are open to supporting the household beyond basic childcare (children’s laundry, meals, keeping common areas and children’s rooms picked up and tidy, etc.).
  • Home Comforts: Your child(ren) remains in a familiar space, with their own books, toys, and routines, which helps create smoother days.
  • Parental Peace of Mind: Real-time updates and close communication with one trusted caregiver provide added comfort and confidence for working parents. You also reduce exposure to illnesses.
  • Schedules that Match your Life: Non-traditional schedules such as part-time or longer hours are possible when creating a nanny job description.
  • Cost Efficiency for Multiple Children: There is often no rate difference between one and two children, unless a new child is born during the placement. In those cases, a small hourly increase ($1–2/hour) is standard.

There’s no one-size-fits-all solution, but many families find that the personalized care and flexibility of a nanny is worth the investment. Mom’s Best Friend has served families for over 30 years and is here to help you find someone who is experienced, trustworthy, and the right fit for your home. Book a free consultation with Jessica now to start your nanny search.